How we review forex brokers
Every Brokercaster review is scored on the same five criteria, using the broker’s own documents and regulators’ public registers. This page explains exactly what we check, how scores are calculated and what we never let influence them.
The five criteria we score
Each criterion gets a score from 0 to 10 with a short reason that appears on the review. The overall Brokercaster score is the simple average of the five, rounded to one decimal.
| Criterion | What we check |
|---|---|
| Licence and safety | Which company would hold your account and who regulates it; licence numbers on the regulator’s register; segregation of client money; negative balance protection; compensation schemes; regulatory warnings |
| Trading costs | Spreads and mark-ups, commissions per platform, swap charges, and non-trading fees such as withdrawal and inactivity fees, worked out on a standard trade |
| Platforms | Which platforms are offered (MetaTrader 4/5, cTrader, TradingView, the broker’s own app), whether they are available on every account type, copy trading and order tools |
| Deposits and withdrawals | Minimum deposit, payment methods, deposit and withdrawal fees, stated processing times and the rules for returning funds |
| Support | Support hours, channels (chat, email, phone, messaging apps) and languages |
How the licence score works
This is where we are strictest, because it decides what protection you actually get. Many international brokers hold tier-1 licences (for example FCA, ASIC or CySEC) in some group companies but open accounts for international clients through an offshore company. We score the company you would sign with, not the best licence in the group.
| Score | Typical situation |
|---|---|
| 9–10 | Your account is held by a company with a tier-1 licence, segregated client money and access to a compensation scheme |
| 7–8 | Offshore company in a group that also holds tier-1 licences, with segregated funds and negative balance protection |
| 5–6 | Offshore licence only, or important protections not stated |
| Below 5 | No verifiable licence, or regulatory warnings against the company |
What the overall score means
| Overall score | Label on the review |
|---|---|
| 8.5 and above | Excellent |
| 7.0 to 8.4 | Good |
| 5.5 to 6.9 | Average |
| Below 5.5 | Weak |
Where our information comes from
- The broker’s official website and legal documents: client agreements, product disclosure documents, cost pages and restricted-country lists.
- Regulators’ public registers: to confirm the company name and licence number of each entity.
- Official app-store listings: app ratings come from the App Store and Google Play and are refreshed automatically each week; we state which country’s store we use.
We do not copy figures from other review sites or from promotional material. When official pages contradict each other (for example two different maximum leverage figures), we show both and say so. Every review lists its sources and the date it was last checked.
Country pages
On our best brokers by country pages, a broker is listed only when its own documents show that it accepts residents of that country. For each broker we name the company you would contract with, its regulator and whether it holds a local licence. Where local law restricts trading with foreign brokers, the page explains the law instead of listing brokers.
Independence and how we make money
Brokercaster may show advertising, which is always labelled “Ad”. Advertisers cannot buy a review, a score, a ranking position or the removal of negative information. We never accept payment for positive reviews.
Links to brokers
Links to brokers on Brokercaster, such as the “Website” buttons, go straight to the broker’s official website. We do not use affiliate or referral links, so we earn nothing when you open an account. Account conditions such as spreads and commissions are set by the broker, so check them in the broker’s client area before you trade.
- Advertising never changes a review, a score, a ranking or a comparison verdict.
- Every broker is reviewed and listed the same way, whether or not it advertises with us.
- A broker cannot pay to remove negative information, warnings or user reviews.
Updates and corrections
Brokers change fees, platforms and licences often. Each review shows when it was last checked, and we update reviews when conditions change. If you find an error, email info@brokercaster.com with the page and an official source; confirmed corrections are made and the review date is updated.
FAQ
Do brokers pay for their Brokercaster score?
No. Scores come only from the criteria on this page. Advertising on the site is labelled “Ad” and never changes a review, a score or a ranking.
Does Brokercaster earn money from broker links?
No. Links to brokers go to their official websites without affiliate or referral codes, so we earn nothing when you open an account. Brokercaster is funded by banner advertising, which has no effect on our ratings: scores come only from the five criteria on this page.
Why does a broker with an FCA licence still get a lower licence score?
Because the FCA licence may belong to a different company in the group. We score the company that would actually hold your account, which for international clients is often an offshore entity.
How often are reviews updated?
Each review shows the date it was last checked. We re-check fees, licences and conditions when a broker changes them and whenever we update the page.
How can I report a mistake?
Email info@brokercaster.com with the page and the official source. If the source confirms it, we correct the page and update its date.
