Deriv vs XM: which broker is better in 2026?
XM has firm negative balance protection and 1,400+ instruments; Deriv adds cTrader, TradingView, synthetic indices and options.
Brokercaster editorial team · Last checked 12 November 2026 · How we review
Deriv
7.2Good - Your account is held byoffshore companies (BVI, Cayman, Mauritius, Vanuatu, Labuan) or companies with no named regulator
- Min. depositNo account minimum on Deriv MT5
- Founded1999
XM
7.4Good - Your account is held byNo: XM International MU Limited is regulated by the FSC Mauritius (offshore)
- Min. depositUSD 5 (Standard and Ultra Low)
- FoundedFounding year not stated on the site; the group's CySEC licence dates from 5 August 2010
Quick verdict
Choose Deriv if…
- You trade on cTrader or TradingView, or want options and multipliers
- You want 99 Derived Indices (Deriv’s synthetic indices) that trade 24/7
- You want 72 published payment methods, including mobile money and Deriv P2P
Choose XM if…
- You want negative balance protection as a stated rule (Deriv’s General Terms make it discretionary)
- You want one licensed company for your account (at Deriv the company depends on the product)
- You want 24/7 phone support in more than 30 languages (Deriv publishes no phone line)
Brokercaster scores compared
| Criterion | Deriv | XM |
|---|---|---|
| Licence and safety | 5 / 10 | 6 / 10 |
| Trading costs | 7 / 10 | 6 / 10 |
| Platforms | 9 / 10 | 8 / 10 |
| Deposits and withdrawals | 8 / 10 | 8 / 10 |
| Support | 7 / 10 | 9 / 10 |
| Overall | 7.2 (Good) | 7.4 (Good) |
Scores come from each full review and follow our methodology. Green marks the higher score.
Key facts side by side
| Feature | Deriv | XM |
|---|---|---|
| Tier-1 licence for your account | No – international accounts sit with offshore companies (BVI, Cayman, Mauritius, Vanuatu, Labuan) or companies with no named regulator; only EEA residents get the MFSA-licensed EU company | No – XM International MU Limited is regulated by the FSC Mauritius (offshore); the CySEC company serves EEA residents only |
| Negative balance protection | Unknown: the CFD page promises zero-balance protection, but the General Terms (cl. 9) leave it to Deriv's sole discretion | Yes – per account (may be withheld in cases of abuse or arbitrage) |
| Min. deposit | No account minimum on Deriv MT5; deposits from USD 5 (cards USD 10); Deriv Trader options from USD 1 stake with USD 5 in the account | USD 5 (Standard and Ultra Low); USD 10,000 for the Shares account |
| Max leverage | 1:1000 on major forex (Deriv MT5, international); fixed per instrument: gold and Bitcoin 1:800, US indices 1:400; EU retail 1:30 | 1:1000 (equity up to USD 40,000), 1:500 to USD 80,000, 1:200 to USD 200,000, 1:100 above; Turbo Stocks 1:200; Shares 1:1; EEA (CySEC) 1:30 |
| Raw spread / ECN account | Zero Spread account on Deriv MT5: spreads from 0 pips plus a commission (amount not published) | No – for international clients: Ultra Low has spreads from 0.8 pips and no commission; the XM Zero account is offered only by the EU company |
| Trading platforms | Deriv MT5, Deriv cTrader, TradingView, Deriv Trader, Deriv Bot, SmartTrader, Deriv app (iOS, Android), Deriv Exchange, Deriv P2P | MetaTrader 4 (incl. MultiTerminal), MetaTrader 5, MT4/MT5 WebTrader and the XM App (iOS, Android) |
| Copy trading | Yes – Deriv cTrader copy trading and MQL5 signals on Deriv MT5 | Yes – XM Copy Trading, free for investors; Strategy Managers earn up to 50% profit share |
| Islamic account | Swap-Free account on Deriv MT5 (no swaps, spreads from 0.3 pips); not labelled Islamic | Yes: swap-free on request for clients who cannot use swaps for religious reasons; fair value adjustments still apply to cash energies and spot metals |
| Founded | 1999 (Deriv Group); holding company Deriv.com Limited, Guernsey | Founding year not stated on the site; the group's CySEC licence dates from 5 August 2010 |
| App ratings ( store) | App Store 4.7 (54) Google Play 4.2 (14.5K) |
App Store 4.6 (2.3K) Google Play 4.5 (149.7K) |
Safety and the company that holds your account
| Deriv | XM | |
|---|---|---|
| Company for international clients | Depends on product and country: Deriv (BVI) Ltd first for MT5 Standard and Zero Spread | XM International MU Limited, Mauritius |
| Licence | BVI FSC SIBA/L/18/1114; other MT5 companies in Cayman, Mauritius, Vanuatu, Labuan | FSC Mauritius, Investment Dealer licence GB23202700 |
| Companies with no named regulator | Samoa (options), SVG (Swap-Free MT5, cTrader, P2P, Wallet), Panama (Deriv Exchange) | None for the international account |
| Segregated client money | Group statement; spelled out only in the Cayman terms | Yes, possibly pooled in an omnibus account |
| Negative balance protection | Discretionary in the General Terms (the CFD page calls it guaranteed) | Yes, per account (may be withheld in cases of abuse or arbitrage) |
| Compensation | Financial Commission fund EUR 20,000; no statutory scheme | None for international clients |
| Founded | 1999 | Founding year not stated; group CySEC licence since 5 August 2010 |
XM. Both hold international accounts offshore. XM uses one licensed company and states negative balance protection per account; at Deriv the company changes with the product, three companies name no regulator and negative balance protection is left to Deriv’s discretion in the contract.
Fees compared
| Cost | Deriv | XM |
|---|---|---|
| Commission-free account | Standard MT5: EUR/USD minimum spread 0.6 pip | Standard: EUR/USD from 1.6 pips; Ultra Low: from 0.8 pips |
| Raw-spread account | Zero Spread MT5: from 0 pips plus a commission (amount not published) | Not offered to international clients (XM Zero is EU-only) |
| Average spreads published | No (minimum and target spreads per instrument) | No (live spreads only in the platform) |
| Deposit and withdrawal fees | None stated by Deriv; the payment method may charge | None from XM |
| Inactivity / dormancy | Adjustment after 12 months without transactions, then every 6 months; amount not published | USD 10 per month after 90 days without activity |
Hard to call. Deriv’s minimum EUR/USD spread on Standard MT5 is lower than XM’s Ultra Low, and only Deriv has a raw-spread account, but Deriv does not publish its Zero Spread commission or its dormancy charge. XM’s dormancy fee starts after 90 days.
Accounts and minimum deposit
| Deriv | XM | |
|---|---|---|
| Live account types | Deriv MT5 Standard, Zero Spread, Swap-Free, Financial, Gold; Deriv cTrader; Deriv Trader | Standard, Ultra Low (each also as micro), Shares |
| Minimum deposit | No account minimum on Deriv MT5; payments from USD 5 (cards USD 10) | USD 5 on Standard and Ultra Low; USD 10,000 on Shares |
| Micro account | Not published | Micro versions of Standard and Ultra Low (1 lot = 1,000 units) |
| Islamic / swap-free | Swap-Free MT5 account (spreads from 0.3 pips); not labelled Islamic | On request for religious reasons |
| Options and multipliers | Deriv Trader: from a USD 1 stake with USD 5 in the account (Samoa company) | Not offered |
| Demo | Unlimited virtual funds; MT5 demo may be deleted after 30 days of inactivity | Yes; closed after 60 days of inactivity |
Close. Both can be opened with about USD 5. XM adds micro-lot accounts and real shares; Deriv adds options and multipliers, held by a company with no named regulator.
Leverage and margin call / stop out
| Deriv | XM | |
|---|---|---|
| Major forex | 1:1000 (fixed per instrument) | 1:1000 for equity up to USD 40,000 |
| How it is set | Fixed per instrument: gold and Bitcoin 1:800, US indices 1:400 | By equity: 1:500 to USD 80,000, 1:200 to USD 200,000, 1:100 above |
| Margin call | Alert only; no percentage published | 50% |
| Stop out | 50% (Deriv may change it at its discretion) | 20% (Shares account 0%) |
No winner. Both offer 1:1000 on major forex. Deriv keeps it fixed per instrument and stops out at 50%; XM lowers leverage as equity grows and stops out at 20%.
Platforms and apps
| Deriv | XM | |
|---|---|---|
| MetaTrader | MT5 (Deriv MT5) | MT4 and MT5 (plus WebTrader and MT4 MultiTerminal) |
| cTrader | Yes, Deriv cTrader | No |
| TradingView trading | Yes | No |
| Own platforms and app | Deriv Trader, Deriv Bot, SmartTrader, Deriv app | XM App (iOS, Android) |
| Copy trading | Deriv cTrader copy trading and MQL5 signals on MT5 | XM Copy Trading, free for investors; managers take up to 50% profit share |
| Instruments | Deriv MT5: forex 70, Derived Indices 99, stocks 456, indices 18, commodities 17, crypto 37, ETFs 31 | Over 1,400, including real shares in the Shares account |
Deriv for platform choice; XM for range. Both offer copy trading. Deriv’s Derived Indices have no outside market: Deriv sets the price and takes the other side of every trade.
Deposits, withdrawals and support
| Deriv | XM | |
|---|---|---|
| Payment methods | 72 methods published: cards, e-wallets, mobile money, online banking, crypto, vouchers, Deriv P2P | Cards, bank transfers, local transfers and e-wallets; listed after login |
| Withdrawal times | Cards up to 1 working day; Skrill and Neteller instant | Processed instantly by an automated system; cards and wires usually 2–5 business days |
| Withdrawal rule | Withdraw with the method you deposited with; P2P deposits only via P2P | No payments to third parties unless XM agrees in writing; funds not used as margin can be withdrawn |
| Support hours | 24/7 | 24/7 |
| Channels | Live chat and WhatsApp; no phone line and no general support email | Live chat, phone (+66 and +230 numbers), email, WhatsApp and Telegram; more than 30 languages |
Close. Deriv publishes more payment methods before sign-up; XM offers phone and email support next to chat.
FAQ
Is Deriv or XM better?
It depends on what you need. Deriv suits traders who want cTrader, TradingView, synthetic indices or options. XM suits traders who want stated negative balance protection, one licensed company, 1,400+ instruments and phone support.
Which is safer, Deriv or XM?
XM. Its international accounts sit with one FSC Mauritius licensee and it states negative balance protection per account. At Deriv the company depends on the product, three group companies name no regulator and the General Terms make negative balance protection discretionary.
Which is cheaper, Deriv or XM?
Hard to say. Deriv’s Standard MT5 EUR/USD starts at 0.6 pip against 0.8 pips on XM Ultra Low, and only Deriv has a raw-spread account, but Deriv does not publish the Zero Spread commission or its dormancy charge. XM charges USD 10 a month after 90 days without activity.
What is the minimum deposit at Deriv and XM?
Deriv has no account minimum on Deriv MT5, with payments from USD 5 (cards USD 10). XM asks USD 5 on Standard and Ultra Low and USD 10,000 on the Shares account.
Which has higher leverage?
Both offer up to 1:1000 on major forex. Deriv fixes leverage per instrument and stops out at 50%; XM lowers leverage above USD 40,000 of equity and stops out at 20%.
Do Deriv and XM offer synthetic indices?
Only Deriv, with 99 Derived Indices that trade 24/7. Deriv sets their price and is the counterparty to every trade. XM offers CFDs and shares on real markets.
Read the full reviews
Deriv review · XM review · All brokers
